In a significant move aimed at broadening investment opportunities for American workers, President Donald Trump has signed an executive order facilitating access to alternative assets within 401(k) retirement plans. This order paves the way for individuals to potentially invest their retirement savings in sectors such as private equity, cryptocurrency, and real estate.
The administration touts the executive order as a victory for the asset management industry, which stands to gain from the estimated $12.2 trillion currently held in Americans’ 401(k) accounts. By allowing investments in private assets, the administration claims that everyday Americans will have access to a wider array of financial opportunities, potentially enhancing their retirement savings.
Robert Brokamp, a financial planning expert at The Motley Fool, noted that this could enable numerous Americans to invest in a more diverse range of companies.
“The theoretical benefits are that everyday Americans can invest in a broader menu of companies,” Brokamp said.
However, experts warn that these alternative investments come with heightened risks and do not necessarily guarantee better returns. Critics caution that the lack of transparency and liquidity in private markets could jeopardize individuals’ retirement savings, particularly during market downturns.
“There is a lot less transparency and liquidity in private markets,” Brokamp added. “There’s not as much information about the companies, and it could be hard to sell your investments—especially during a panic when many investors are trying to sell all at once.”
In addition to the risks associated with private investments, there are also financial implications. Typical 401(k) investments, such as mutual funds and ETFs, often charge fees around 0.3%. In contrast, private funds might impose management fees ranging from 1% to 2% and performance fees as high as 20%.
According to Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at Better Markets, interval funds can charge anywhere from 2% to 3%, significantly impacting returns for investors who may already be wary of fee structures.
While private equity has technically been permissible in retirement plans, widespread adoption has been limited. Some companies, like BlackRock, are exploring new offerings, and while some avenues for crypto investments in 401(k)s exist, they are currently not prevalent.
The new executive order aims to change this by mandating a review of the Department of Labor’s current guidelines regarding alternative assets within 180 days. It also instructs the Securities and Exchange Commission to explore methods to facilitate access to these assets for 401(k) plans and similar investment vehicles.
Experts like Schiffrin believe this directive could lead to a surge in private market investments in retirement plans, as 401(k) plan managers may have previously hesitated due to regulatory uncertainties. “I think this is going to open the floodgates,” Schiffrin stated, anticipating a shift in the investment landscape as companies weigh the option of including private market assets.
However, there is skepticism among employers, who may be hesitant to offer these plans due to potential liability for losses endured by employees. Increased clarity from the government might help in alleviating these concerns, yet many experts warn that the benefits of adding alternative assets to retirement plans might not outweigh the risks.
Certified financial planner and attorney Anh Tran voiced concerns about less-informed investors potentially being drawn to the promise of higher returns from alternative investments, without comprehending the full scope of risks involved. She advises against such investments for individuals who lack a comprehensive understanding of their retirement portfolios.
“It could be detrimental to less-informed investors whose only investment account is their 401(k),” Tran remarked. “Without proper guardrails, such as limiting exposure to 5% to 10% of the portfolio, these investors could be exposed to unnecessary risk, misaligned expectations, and potentially irreversible losses.”
Knut Rostad, co-founder and president of the nonprofit Institute for the Fiduciary Standard, shared similar apprehensions. He warns that the inclusion of private assets in 401(k)s may lead to significant financial repercussions for retirement savers.
“I think in practice, there’ll be many fiduciaries who ignore this directive because they understand precisely what will result from it,” Rostad argued, foreseeing a scenario where numerous individuals suffer significant losses in their retirement accounts as a result of the expanded investment options.
The integration of cryptocurrencies into 401(k) portfolios also raises additional concerns. As Schiffrin noted, the absence of established protections for investors poses a considerable risk when considering crypto investments in retirement plans.
The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (SIFMA), representing broker-dealers, investment banks, and asset managers, expressed enthusiasm regarding the executive order. President Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr. noted that the expansion of access to private market investments could enhance diversification and democratize investment opportunities for everyday retirement savers.
Bentsen remarked, “As more U.S. companies choose to remain non-public, private markets have developed into a more robust asset class. Policy changes to expand access to private market investments could serve to improve diversification, democratize access, and offer more investment choices.”
Although it may take several months for substantial changes to materialize, many experts are calling for an emphasis on education and safeguards to protect investors—particularly younger individuals and those lacking professional financial guidance. Tran stressed the need for transparency and educational resources to minimize risks and prevent possible financial harm.
“There must be transparency, education, and limits in place to prevent widespread harm,” she concluded. “Otherwise, we could be setting the stage for not only financial loss, but broader economic and social consequences.”
image source from：nbcnews
