The ongoing trade tensions between Canada and the United States have escalated significantly, resulting in serious consequences for the American wine industry. Canada’s recent decision to boycott American-made wines in response to the Trump administration’s global tariffs has compounded the struggles faced by U.S. winemakers.
According to Robert Koch, president and CEO of the California Wine Institute, Canada is the most important export market for U.S. wines, with retail sales exceeding $1.1 billion annually.
In a coordinated response to the tariffs imposed by the Trump administration, Canada enacted a boycott against all U.S.-made wines and alcohol, removing these products from liquor and wine store shelves, as well as restaurants across the country. This boycott began in Ontario and rapidly spread to other provinces. In a social media video, Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew publicly mocked the Trump administration, highlighting the impact of the executive order on the availability of American wines in Canada.
As a result of this initiative, there has emerged a sense of national pride in Canada regarding the decision to avoid American products. Mike Kaiser, executive vice president and director of government affairs for Wine America, emphasized that the shift in consumer sentiment is a direct consequence of the current trade disputes.
The outcomes of the boycott and tariffs could prove catastrophic for the U.S. wine industry, which has already been under stress. Kaiser pointed out that some winemakers might be able to absorb the tariffs, but the loss of $1 billion in sales from unsold wine already in Canada deeply disrupts the entire domestic wine market.
Despite the potential for some tariffs to be lifted, Kaiser expressed concern about the lasting psychological impact of the tariffs on consumers, suggesting that even if disputes are resolved, consumer perceptions may not easily revert back.
The American wine industry was grappling with various challenges prior to the introduction of tariffs, exacerbated by trends in consumer behavior. Christi Coors Ficeli, CEO of Goosecross Cellars in Napa Valley, noted that wine consumption in the U.S. saw a decline post-COVID pandemic, which resulted in reduced sales and inconsistent winery visits. Moreover, the popularity of alternative alcoholic beverages like White Claw and High Noon has drawn consumers away from wine.
Adding to the industry’s woes, U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy recently suggested that even moderate wine consumption could pose health risks, leading some potential drinkers to reconsider their choices. Coupled with the rising costs of wine and winery visits due to inflation, the financial strain is evident throughout the industry. Ficeli expressed that the increased costs associated with inflation, especially for essentials like glass, have distorted pricing for tourists and consumers.
Frequent Napa Valley visitor Wanda Newman Johnson shared her concerns about the tariffs and their effects on small businesses within the wine industry. Having memberships with several Napa wineries, she is wary about her future purchases and the ongoing viability of these establishments due to the tariffs.
Ficeli further elaborated on the financial strain faced by wineries in Napa, where rising operational costs continue to be a significant obstacle. She lamented that the need to raise prices to accommodate the costs of imported bottles and barrels is necessary, but it risks alienating customers who may find it increasingly expensive to buy wine or visit wineries.
Many American wineries, like Goosecross Cellars, rely on imports for essentials, with high tariffs making it cost-prohibitive for them to source materials from places like China. The tariffs imposed on Chinese products have created a complicated financial landscape, affecting everything from bottles to barrels to corks.
Ficeli noted that barrel suppliers have presented varying pricing options, with some willing to absorb some of the costs, while others are increasing prices by significant margins. For smaller wineries trying to meet operational costs, such increases can be monumental and unsustainable.
Meanwhile, the impact of tariffs is not limited to California alone. In New York’s Finger Lakes region, where over a hundred wineries are located near Canada, the repercussions have been profound. Scott Osborn, owner of Fox Run Vineyards, reported that approximately 10% of his sales come from Canadian consumers, and his winery has already experienced a 20% decline in business from Canada following the boycott.
Osborn emphasized the significance of Canadian customers who typically visit his winery, enjoy the café services, and purchase wine before returning home. The lack of that customer base and the positive experience they bring will undoubtedly affect his business moving forward.
With the ongoing tariffs, Osborn pointed out that Europeans are also canceling their trips to the region, contributing to a decline in business for wineries that rely on international tourism.
Kaiser highlighted the urgency of the situation, indicating that Congress is currently limited in its ability to influence the administration’s decisions regarding tariffs. He expressed the need for more targeted tariffs, understanding that broader tariffs hurt their industry and calling for collaboration with other countries to protect American wine interests.
Despite the ongoing challenges, Kaiser and Wine America continue to seek opportunities to engage with the U.S. Trade Representative’s Office and other key officials to communicate the detrimental effects of current trade policies on U.S. winemakers.
While the situation appears bleak, industry leaders remain hopeful that constructive dialogue will lead to solutions that can shield the wine industry from further harm. However, they remain acutely aware that the damage already inflicted may take significant time and resources to repair for many wineries across the country.
image source from：https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/american-wine-global-tariffs-canada-boycott-rcna201296
