As the New York Giants prepare for the 2025 NFL Draft, the question of whether they will select a quarterback continues to loom large.
This discussion has echoed from the 2024 draft considerations, where the team opted to delay a definitive decision on the position.
Evaluating the quarterbacks likely to interest the Giants in the early rounds reveals a mix of opinions from scouts and analysts.
### Shedeur Sanders – Colorado
Shedeur Sanders stands out as one of the most-discussed quarterback prospects.
Opinions on him vary widely.
One scout praised Sanders for his poise and ability to start from Day 1, while highlighting that he must adapt to the absence of his father, Deion Sanders, as coach.
With a strong arm and decent mobility, the scout argues that Sanders embodies many traits teams desire in a quarterback.
Conversely, another scout expressed skepticism, labeling him an overhyped game manager unlikely to stand out at the top of the draft
He criticized Sanders for a tendency to play too much like a ‘backyard football player,’ which could pose challenges against professional defenses.
Adding to the mix, NFL writer Mike Tanier stated that Sanders is better suited for a neutral team rather than for a franchise aiming for immediate success.
Pro Football Focus highlighted Sanders’ fundamentals, accuracy, and leadership qualities but cautioned that his size may present challenges at the NFL level.
Matt Waldman compared Sanders to Geno Smith and Tua Tagovailoa, emphasizing his strengths as a distributor while acknowledging he might struggle under pressure.
Todd McShay labeled Sanders the fastest processor in the class and a clear first-round talent, albeit with a need to improve his pocket awareness.
### Jaxson Dart – Ole Miss
Another intriguing prospect is Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss.
Mike Tanier likened Dart’s profile to that of Mitch Trubisky and Daniel Jones, underscoring his deep-ball prowess and decent mechanics but questioning his performance under pressure.
Scouts have suggested Dart offers more upside than many acknowledge, with one favoring him over Sanders due to his moxie and quick thinking.
Though his deep-ball accuracy is under scrutiny, Dart possesses athletic traits that might attract teams looking for potential starters.
Pro Football Focus noted that Dart has excelled in a fast-paced offense but must develop better anticipation skills at the professional level.
While some see him as a potential Day 2 pick, Todd McShay expressed confidence that Dart could deliver significant value for a quarterback-needy team.
### Tyler Shough – Louisville
Tyler Shough’s unique evaluation stems partly from his age; at 26, he carries extensive experience but is somewhat disrupted by an injury history.
One scout highlighted Shough’s athleticism and arm talent, suggesting he could surprise NFL franchises despite inconsistent performances.
Pro Football Focus praised Shough’s size and arm strength but noted that his short-distance accuracy remains a concern.
Matt Waldman identified Shough as a potential under-the-radar pick whose skills could be promising for teams willing to invest in his development.
Todd McShay, however, warned that concerns about Shough’s age could temper his draft appeal, suggesting that teams will need to weigh short-term readiness against long-term potential.
### Jalen Milroe – Alabama
Jalen Milroe is another prospect generating considerable discussion, particularly about his athleticism.
While one scout acknowledged Milroe’s rare physical gifts, others have criticized his accuracy and decision-making, making his projection somewhat turbulent.
Pro Football Focus praised Milroe’s arm strength and deep-ball capabilities, but also raised flags about his inconsistencies and challenges processing defenses.
Matt Waldman firmly believes that Milroe stands out as the most intriguing option in the quarterback class, emphasizing his potential impact if developed correctly.
Todd McShay cautioned that a team selecting Milroe will need to embrace a long-term strategy focused on although he possesses unique dual-threat capabilities.
### Other Quarterback Options
In the event the Giants are unable to land their desired quarterback within the first two rounds, several later-round options could still be on the table.
Will Howard from Ohio State comes with mixed reviews, some scouts believing he could ultimately emerge as the best quarterback in the draft due to his overall capabilities and character.
Conversely, Dillon Gabriel of Oregon faces skepticism due to his size and perceived limitations, with some scouts comparing him to Tua Tagovailoa.
Quinn Ewers from Texas is seen as a player with solid fundamentals but lacking the athleticism to make a significant impact at the professional level.
He’s viewed as more of a backup option despite a promising collegiate career.
Kyle McCord from Syracuse also garners attention; scouts recognize his clean mechanics and high character, though concerns about his decision-making under pressure persist.
### Conclusion
The Giants’ quarterback decision-making heading into the 2025 NFL Draft is set against a backdrop of diverse evaluations and projections.
As they weigh their options and consider which quarterback aligns best with their vision, the potential for excitement and uncertainty unfolds around each prospect’s journey.
Ultimately, addressing the quarterback position remains pivotal for the franchise’s future success.
image source from：https://www.bigblueview.com/2025/4/20/24406427/quarterback-scouting-reports-what-nfl-draft-analysts-scouts-are-saying-about-2025-class
