TALLAHASSEE — In a move reminiscent of the rapid response during Hurricane Ian, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is utilizing his emergency authority to construct a large immigration detention center in the Everglades.
This initiative comes as a reaction to an uptick in Cuban and Haitian migrants arriving by boat in the Florida Keys, which led to a state of emergency declared in January 2023.
DeSantis has mobilized private contractors to develop a facility capable of holding 3,000 detained immigrants and has deployed Florida National Guard troops to secure the area.
Despite the decline in migrant arrivals, the emergency order under which this project is being executed has been extended multiple times, citing President Joe Biden’s insufficient response to immigration challenges.
During a recent visit to the construction site, DeSantis spoke with Fox News, saying, “This is not our first rodeo,” acknowledging the unique challenges of detaining immigrants but emphasizing the state’s logistical capabilities.
However, this swift action has raised concerns among environmentalists and local lawmakers regarding the nature of the emergency prompting such a drastic measure.
Democratic Senator Lori Berman voiced her concerns, asking, “What is the emergency in the state of Florida that we need to build this facility under this timeframe?” She stressed the need for clarity on the existence of an actual emergency.
Another lawmaker, Senator Shevrin Jones, labeled the situation as construction of a prison camp under misleading pretenses of an emergency.
The concept of the detention center, referred to as Alligator Alcatraz due to the swampy surroundings, was first brought to public attention on June 18, just weeks before the estimated opening.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier discussed the facility on Fox News on that day, revealing the project’s details during a helicopter tour of the site.
Ra Schooley, a former flight instructor, reacted to the media coverage by alerting environmental leaders about the plans.
Schooley noted that the swift airport closure announcement from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) took many by surprise, as it was not typical to see such quick action regarding the small airstrip.
On June 21, the airstrip was closed, marking a pivotal moment in the construction timeline as projects began to ramp up with federal approval obtained shortly after.
The ensuing construction involved heavy machinery and contractors working around the clock to prepare the site, transforming the area with tents and trailers.
However, local officials in Collier County received little advance notice of the construction and had many pressing questions about emergency response planning in the case of severe weather.
Kevin Guthrie, head of Florida’s Department of Emergency Management, stated that the camp would undergo federal inspections prior to opening, aiming to assure compliance with operational demands for such a facility.
Despite the rapid progress, questions linger regarding the decision-making process behind the governor’s sweeping actions and whether they set a precedent for similar actions in the future.
The use of emergency powers for this purpose follows a trend seen in Texas, where Governor Greg Abbott similarly invoked emergency authority to seize local land for immigration-related purposes.
Abbott’s approach in Texas has also included securing areas along the border to enhance immigration enforcement, indicating a potential strategy being mirrored by DeSantis in Florida.
With DeSantis’ continued extensions of the emergency order, concerns exist about the implications of such a protracted declaration, especially considering that the declared emergency is rooted in immigration issues rather than a traditional natural disaster.
Ongoing legal challenges may arise as advocacy groups already are disputing the construction of the detention center, arguing that it bypassed necessary procedural reviews typically required for such developments.
Experts note that while governors possess the authority to act quickly in emergencies to maintain safety and order, the circumstances surrounding immigration do not fit neatly into the traditional framework of emergency management.
Chris Reynolds, an emergency management expert, remarked on the unusual nature of DeSantis’ application of emergency powers, asserting that the situation stretches the intended purpose of emergency management statutes.
Yet, he also acknowledged that legally the governor’s actions are permissible, raising pertinent questions about the future utilization of emergency powers in Florida.
As the project advances, the scrutiny placed upon DeSantis’ administration will likely intensify, weaving a complex narrative involving logistical efficiency, environmental concerns, and the limitations of executive authority in times of politically charged crises.
image source from：tampabay
