The ongoing negotiations between the United States and India regarding a trade agreement highlight significant implications for both commerce and security.
President Donald Trump’s administration has been accused of undermining the trust built over years between the two nations by imposing pressure on India to make concessions, particularly regarding agriculture market access.
In a notable move, an executive order issued on August 6 added a 25 percent tariff on Indian products in response to India’s purchases of Russian oil.
This escalation has raised concerns about the overall stability of the U.S.-India relationship, despite the historical cooperation that has characterized their ties in the past.
While memories of contentious periods in 1998 and 2013 linger, it is essential to recognize that a path for reconciliation remains open.
For this to happen, there must be a deeper understanding of India’s firm positions on agricultural market access as well as a consistent approach to its dealings with Russia.
The wider strategic relationship between the U.S. and India is at significant risk if these issues are not addressed promptly.
Working in a capacity that connects U.S.-India commercial relations with defense collaborations, it is evident that both economic and military aspects cannot be treated as separate entities.
The potential of a trade agreement with India presents itself not only in economic terms but also as part of a larger strategic framework, especially given India’s status as a rapidly growing economy.
India is nearing the point of overtaking Germany and Japan to become the world’s third-largest economy, boasting what is destined to be the largest consumer market globally.
This presents a unique opportunity for the U.S. as India has a dynamic technology services sector that can complement American strengths in various industries.
Nonetheless, the urgency of finalizing a beneficial trade deal extends beyond mere commercial interests.
With China’s ongoing commitment to an export-oriented growth strategy, it is imperative that the U.S. views its relationship with India as a vital counterbalance to Chinese influence in the region.
China’s significant trade surpluses empower its military modernization and allow significant investments in regional infrastructure.
Moreover, these resources enable Chinese manufacturers to enhance their capabilities in dual-use sectors, including computers, drones, and critical technologies, which poses a direct challenge to U.S. interests.
As a result, India’s deepening cooperation with the United States in defense is becoming more crucial, involving joint military exercises and increased U.S. arms sales to the Indian armed forces.
India’s participation in U.S.-led naval exercises and the agreements for repairs of U.S. Navy vessels in Indian shipyards reflect the growing partnership in military collaboration.
Moreover, operational coordination has subtly emerged during India’s confrontations, notably with China.
Despite these security advancements, India’s proactive approach in pursuing trade agreements with other nations, such as the UAE, Australia, and the United Kingdom, suggests a desire to diversify its economic partnerships.
These trade agreements not only promote zero-duty access for a majority of tariff lines but also strengthen each signatory’s market position and reduce overreliance on China.
President Donald Trump’s efforts to apply pressure on India have elicited mixed reactions, invoking historical concerns about the reliability of U.S. partnerships.
The unusual diplomatic engagements with Pakistan and heightened rhetoric regarding India’s dealings with Russia have potentially jeopardized goodwill accumulated with India.
While the Biden administration managed to maintain a degree of stability in U.S.-India relations through challenging moments, the escalating tensions under the Trump administration risk overshadowing this progress.
Nevertheless, despite the increased tensions marked by daily tariff threats from the Trump administration, India has chosen to manage its response carefully, avoiding a deeper confrontation.
Tensions may be palpable, but opportunities still exist for both countries to restore a more collaborative diplomatic approach.
Accomplishing a favorable trade agreement, which respects India’s domestic political landscape, is the first significant step towards rebuilding trust.
Beyond this, both nations must also consider additional confidence-building measures to refill the considerably depleted ‘trust reservoir’ that has been critical to their strategic partnership.
Richard Rossow of the Center for Strategic and International Studies emphasizes the necessity of these steps to secure a more robust and comprehensive U.S.-India relationship moving forward.
image source from：csis
