A federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction to block the enforcement of a controversial Washington state law that would require priests to report allegations of abuse revealed during confession.
United States District Judge David G. Estudillo, a Biden appointee, ruled to halt the implementation of Senate Bill 5375, which was scheduled to take effect on July 27.
In his decision, Estudillo highlighted that for the plaintiffs, representing a group of Roman Catholic clergy, violating the confidentiality of confession could lead to severe religious consequences, including automatic excommunication and the risk of spiritual damnation.
Estudillo noted, “There is no question that SB 5375 burdens Plaintiffs’ free exercise of religion.”
He asserted that the law puts clergy in a difficult position, forcing them to choose between adhering to their faith and complying with state law when they encounter confessions concerning child abuse or neglect.
Furthermore, the judge pointed out an inconsistency in the application of the law.
While clergy would be required to report suspicions of child abuse, other adult groups such as attorneys and parents are exempt from mandatory reporting under state law.
“This indicates that SB 5375 is neither neutral nor generally applicable, as it treats religious activity less favorably than comparable secular activity,” Estudillo wrote.
He emphasized that the state failed to provide compelling evidence to justify why an exemption for law professors and their supervisees was acceptable while clergy were not afforded the same consideration.
Mark Rienzi, the president and CEO of Becket, a religious liberty law firm representing the plaintiffs, praised the judge’s ruling.
“This ruling confirms what has always been true: In America, government officials have no business prying into the confessional,” Rienzi stated.
He added that by upholding the seal of confession, the court reinforces the essential principle of religious freedom from government interference.
SB 5375 was introduced in January, extending the list of professionals mandated to report any suspicions of child sexual abuse to authorities, specifically including clergy.
However, the bill faced backlash for not exempting confessional communications from the reporting requirement, a stance that contradicts Catholic doctrine on protecting the sanctity of confession.
The legislation stated, “Except for members of the clergy, no one shall be required to report under this section when he or she obtains the information solely as a result of a privileged communication.”
State Senator Noel Frame, a Democrat from Seattle and the bill’s sponsor, commented on the necessity of the legislation, asserting, “It’s long past time for this protection for children.”
She continued, “Members of the clergy play such an important role in the lives of children, just like teachers and doctors do, and should be considered mandatory reporters as well.”
The bill received support from the Clergy Accountability Coalition, an interfaith advocacy group that contended the measure was vital for combating child abuse.
Sharon Huling from the Coalition stated, “If a state cannot regulate religions, then they should not be able to provide religions with exemptions either.”
In May, a lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington by the bishops of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Seattle and the Dioceses of Spokane and Yakima, along with Catholic priests from the state.
The lawsuit named several state officials, including Washington Governor Bob Ferguson and Attorney General Nicholas Brown, as defendants.
Additionally, the United States Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division initiated an investigation into SB 5375, suggesting that the law may infringe upon First Amendment rights.
As this legal battle continues, the issue of balancing child protection laws with religious freedom remains a contentious topic in Washington state.
image source from：christianpost
