President Donald Trump continues to assert that he may deploy National Guard troops to San Francisco, utilizing claims about rising crime rates as a rationale for his proposals.
However, officials and residents in the city strongly disagree, insisting that crime has actually decreased and San Francisco is recovering from the pandemic’s impact.
Mayor Daniel Lurie firmly stated, “This is a safe American city. We got this in San Francisco,” countering Trump’s assertions.
Trump has previously sent the National Guard to several cities under the pretext of addressing crime, including Washington, D.C., Memphis, Los Angeles, Chicago, and Portland, Oregon.
His focus on San Francisco has bewildered local leaders, as they maintain that Trump’s depiction of the city as plagued by crime is entirely inaccurate.
During a recent Fox News interview, Trump remarked that residents of San Francisco seemed to welcome federal help, a statement that left local citizens puzzled.
Kate Freudenberger, a retail worker in the city, expressed her disbelief at the president’s comments, saying, “You’ve been walking around the city, it’s peaceful, there is no insurrection.”
She highlighted the relative calmness in the city, adding that federal immigration authorities have not been particularly active in San Francisco, unlike in other locations.
Marc Benioff, CEO of Salesforce, stirred controversy earlier this month when he suggested that he would welcome the National Guard for his business conference, a statement he later apologized for, emphasizing the conference’s safety and success without federal intervention.
San Francisco has been on the road to recovery following the damage inflicted by the coronavirus pandemic, which left the downtown area desolate and highlighted issues of homelessness and drug abuse.
The local economy is showing signs of improvement, with a significant rise in artificial intelligence firms seeking office space.
Reports indicate a 21% increase in office visits compared to last year, bolstered by public transit usage bouncing back to pre-pandemic levels.
The Wall Street Journal has noted that San Francisco is emerging from what it referred to as a “doom loop,” a sentiment that Mayor Lurie was eager to share on social media.
In various neighborhoods, such as the Tenderloin, city officials and nonprofit organizations have taken initiatives to improve the area, with workers helping children cross the street and cleaning up trash.
Although challenges remain in places experiencing high drug use, overall crime rates have decreased by more than 26% compared to the same period last year, according to the San Francisco Police Department.
Lurie emphasized that property crimes, specifically vehicle break-ins, have reached a 22-year low, demonstrating significant progress in public safety.
While Lurie expressed a willingness to accept federal assistance to combat drug trafficking, he was adamant that deploying troops would not be an effective solution.
In his statement, he asserted, “The National Guard does not have the authority to arrest drug dealers—and sending them to San Francisco will do nothing to get fentanyl off the streets or make our city safer.”
In the 2024 elections, voters in San Francisco granted police new tools to address crime, including the use of drones and surveillance cameras.
Moreover, a change in the district attorney’s office occurred when voters recalled progressive DA Chesa Boudin, replacing him with Brooke Jenkins, perceived as tougher on crime.
Efforts to bolster the police force have also been fruitful, with a 40% increase in entry-level police applications compared to the previous year.
On the state level, California Governor Gavin Newsom’s administration has made it clear it would resist any federal deployment of the National Guard similar to past instances where he opposed Trump’s orders.
In response to possible troop deployments, Attorney General Rob Bonta stated that he would challenge such actions in court, as seen in litigation efforts from other Democratic officials in cities like Chicago and Portland that successfully blocked similar measures.
Retired nurse Libby Baxter voiced her concerns about the potential chaos that could arise if the National Guard is dispatched to San Francisco.
She commented, “I believe that that may happen if they come to San Francisco because we are a very tolerant community, but we don’t do well with somebody coming in and trying to dictate or take over certain parts of our city.”
The ongoing tension reflects the broader national discourse surrounding crime, governance, and the perception of safety in American cities, particularly those managed by Democratic leaders.
As the city continues its positive trajectory, the local administration remains focused on addressing public safety and community welfare without the need for federal intervention.
image source from：abcnews
