Cookies are a beloved comfort food that never goes out of style, offering solace and joy whether enjoyed warm fresh from the oven or as an afternoon snack. Seattle, with its vibrant food culture, has become a hotbed for cookie enthusiasts, boasting an array of unique cookie offerings from bakeries, coffee shops, and even grocery stores. This guide aims to showcase some of the best cookies Seattle has to offer, organized geographically to help you navigate through this delicious scene.
Starting off with a standout creation, Ben’s Bread offers a blue corn cookie that is unlike any other. Combining the starchy corniness with buttery dough, this cookie balances sweet and savory flavors, echoing the taste of cornbread. Although it’s delightful on its own, warming it up with a pat of butter and a drizzle of honey elevates the experience even further.
Bell’s Cookie Co. is another gem located across from Green Lake and boasts a colorful atmosphere. Founded by CIA-trained culinary consultant Brooke Perez and her husband Tomas, this cookie spot is known for its gourmet twists on traditional flavors. Make sure to try the Bell’s cookie which is generously packed with toffee, chocolate chips, pecans, and potato chips, offering a chewy-crunchy texture reminiscent of a candy bar.
A unique find in Sunset Hill is the farmers market favorite that recently opened a brick-and-mortar shop. Famous for their extraordinary onion cookie, this bakery creatively blends caramelized Walla Walla onions with warm cinnamon sugar, crafting a vegan twist on the classic snickerdoodle. For those who enjoy a playful flavor combination, this cookie echoes the taste sensation of cinnamon and everything bagel experiences combined into one delightful treat.
For something that fuses German and Chinese flavors, look no further than the cafe known for its inventive chocolate chip cookie. Infused with black pepper and salty licorice caramel, this cookie offers a bold twist on a classic favorite. Even if you’re not a licorice fan, this flavorful treat has been designed to appeal to a broad palette, with the option to enjoy it alongside a spicy lava hot chocolate.
Seattle’s cookie craze arguably began with the popular chain Hello Robin, which opened in 2013. With its transparent kitchen where you can witness their hand-scooping cookie process, this bakery is a must-visit with multiple locations. The cookies here are small and affordable, allowing you to easily sample from a rotating selection of around 14 flavors. Notable choices include the delicate birthday cake cookie featuring sprinkles and creamy white chocolate, the spicy chocolate orange habanero, and the Totes Oats with an oatmeal twist to the classic chocolate chip.
Capitol Hill’s buzzworthy bakery operates exclusively from Friday to Sunday, drawing cookies enthusiasts in droves. While their rice crispy treats take the spotlight, the vegan yuzu crinkle cookies are making waves with their vibrant flavor profile. Filled with tangy yuzu juice and candied peel, they offer a burst of citrus that is perfectly complemented by a fluffy, soft texture. Other options include a fascinating pandan cookie adorned with crunchy coconut crumble, offering a distinctly buttery and toasty flavor.
Shikorina, which began as a small bakery in the Central District, has transformed into a larger operation in the Pike/Pine corridor. Their bebere caramel cookie has gained recognition as one of Seattle’s most distinctive cookies, combining a soft dough with nutty crushed walnuts and a runny caramel filling enhanced by Ethiopian berbere spice. For a taste adventure, the chai-spiced oatmeal white chocolate and floral honey snickerdoodles are worth trying as well.
Midnight Cookie Co. caters to late-night cravings, offering sizable cookies until the early hours of the morning. Their nostalgic flavors, from traditional chocolate chip to candy-loaded varieties like M&M, deliver satisfying sweetness and may even be delivered right to your door. The convenience and unique late-night availability make this spot a local favorite.
If you prefer dense, chewy cookies, make your way to Lowrider’s cookies, which are known for their fudgy texture. Indulge in flavors such as the Oreo-packed Cookies and Cream cookie or the Salted Toffee Pecan cookie for a gooey treat. Seasonal specialties keep cookie lovers excited, particularly with their annual Stuffed Strawberry Poptart cookie that encapsulates a burst of juicy fruit within sweet dough.
At Pike Market, a humble stand may be popular for its cinnamon buns, but the oversized cookies here steal the show. With a perfect combination of crispy edges and a soft, chewy center, these massive cookies are loaded with an abundance of mix-ins. The Monster cookie doesn’t hold back either, incorporating oats, nuts, chocolate chips, and M&Ms for a truly extraordinary delight.
For a truly remarkable cookie experience, Metropolitan Market offers “the cookie” that stands out among its peers. Their chocolate chip cookie is generously filled with two types of Belgian chocolate chunks, creating a delightful mess as it melts in your mouth. The addition of toasted walnuts brings a welcomed crunch to balance the melty chocolate, making it deeply nostalgic of the joy that comes with indulging in a warm cookie right out of the oven. The memory of licking your fingers clean afterward is a fond one that nobody can separate from this experience.
Finally, Little Jaye offers a chocolate chip cookie that, while modest in appearance, carries big flavors. The chef-owner, Charlie Garriosn, drew inspiration from tasting 40 local cookies before landing on his own ideal recipe. His cookies are characterized by the perfect balance of molassesy brown sugar flavor and a crumbly crisp texture.
Seasonal varieties ensure there is always something new to entice customers, but don’t miss the candy-loaded monster cookie that is a delightful combination of M&Ms, Butterfingers, and peanut butter cups in each bite.
In conclusion, Seattle’s cookie scene is as diverse and rich as the city’s culinary landscape itself. With each neighborhood offering its delicious creations, there’s plenty to satisfy every cookie lover’s cravings. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these spots are definitely worth checking out to indulge in the warm, comforting, and often adventurous world of cookies right here in Seattle.
image source from：https://seattle.eater.com/maps/the-best-cookies-in-seattle
