In a pivotal move toward reducing air pollution, the Los Angeles basin is set to phase out new household water heaters and heating systems powered by natural gas under two draft rules proposed by the South Coast Air Quality Management District.
These regulations, which will be voted on this Friday, mandate that manufacturers sell a growing percentage of zero-emission heating appliances in the four-county region.
The draft rules begin with a target of 30% zero-emission appliances by 2027, with manufacturers required to pay fees for any continuing sales of natural gas units.
According to air quality officials, home appliances are among the largest remaining sources of smog-causing gases in the L.A. basin, and these new measures could eliminate a significant portion of air pollutants.
The South Coast Air Quality Management District claims the proposed actions would yield one of the highest reductions in pollutants seen from any regulatory rule in decades.
While consumers will not need to replace their appliances immediately, they will be encouraged to opt for zero-emission heat pumps powered by electricity when their natural gas systems fail.
The air district estimates that nearly 200,000 furnaces and 300,000 water heaters will need replacing each year, given the average lifespans of 25 years for heating systems and 15 years for water heaters.
However, the cost of transitioning to heat pumps varies significantly. Replacing an entire HVAC system with a heat pump may not be more expensive than a natural gas alternative, according to district estimates, while switching out just a natural gas water heater may incur a cost of $2,000 more, and replacing just a furnace could cost an additional $8,000.
Opposition to the proposed phaseout is notable among contractors and developers, who argue that fees imposed on manufacturers will ultimately be passed on to consumers, businesses, and landlords.
Brian Johsz, advocacy manager for the Los Angeles County Business Federation, expressed concerns over the financial burden these rules could impose on residents, particularly at a time when many are already struggling to meet their living costs.
SoCalGas also voiced its discontent with the proposed regulations, warning that they could limit consumer choices and result in increased costs for appliances.
The company claims that the measures might be subject to preemption under federal law due to its potential to effectively ban appliances governed by the Energy Policy and Conservation Act.
In a letter to the air district, Kevin Barker, a senior manager for SoCalGas’s energy and environmental policy, argued that forcing consumers to replace their natural gas appliances would lead to significant increases in costs at a time when affordable energy solutions are desperately needed.
Conversely, the air quality officials maintain that residents will experience cost savings in the long run by making the switch to electric heaters.
The South Coast district estimates that households in the affected region will save between $191 million and $250 million in utility costs annually from 2027 to 2061 as a result of this transition.
Manufacturers currently have two options for compliance: they can either switch to selling entirely zero-emission units by 2027 or pay a fee for each natural gas appliance sold, with those fees designated to provide incentives for low-income residents and landlords to invest in heat pumps.
Environmental advocates argue that the air agency should accelerate its efforts, noting that the L.A. region continues to grapple with the worst smog in the nation despite years of remediation initiatives.
Chris Chavez, the deputy policy director with the Clean Air Coalition, highlighted that opportunities for further emission reductions remain, which may be neglected in the current proposals.
Originally, the air district had planned more aggressive targets, mandating that manufacturers would have to achieve 100% zero-emission appliance sales by 2031.
However, following significant pushback from the business sector and gas companies regarding affordability, the agency amended its stance, resulting in the current draft proposal which sets phased targets of 30% compliance by 2027, increasing to 50% in 2029, 75% in 2033, and 90% by 2036.
With compliance fees structured between $500 and $50 for each continuing sale of natural gas appliances, the air district anticipates that by 2061, 90% of water heaters and furnaces in the region will be zero emissions.
Chavez noted that the new proposal will yield only six tons of nitrogen oxide emissions reductions per day, a substantial decrease from the previously projected 10 tons.
Nihal Shrinath, representing the Sierra Club, criticized the amendments, suggesting that they reflect the influences of gas lobbying efforts and undermine years of progress toward clean energy goals.
He emphasized the urgency for the air district to enhance its regulatory frameworks, especially given the public health implications tied to air quality noncompliance.
The governing board of the South Coast district is preparing for a public hearing and subsequent voting on these updated emissions regulations, which aim to revise rules set in place as far back as 1978 and 1982.
Research indicates that gas appliances in the Los Angeles region are responsible for higher emissions of nitrogen oxides and fine particles than power plants, oil refineries, and gas production combined.
The ten million water heaters and furnaces operating in this basin collectively emit around seven tons of nitrogen oxides and 1.5 tons of fine particles each day.
In comparative terms, emissions from oil refineries, the largest industrial polluters in the area, are lower than those produced by gas appliances.
Vehicles currently represent the largest single source of nitrogen oxides, releasing approximately 11.5 tons daily.
Air quality experts point out the severe health implications of these emissions, including their contribution to smog formation, which exacerbates respiratory conditions like asthma, in addition to deteriorating indoor air quality.
The projected health benefits of these regulations are substantial, equating to billions in savings through reduced healthcare expenses over time.
According to estimates from the air district, implementing these rules could lead to $59 billion in cumulative health savings between 2027 and 2053.
Moreover, the reduction of pollution could prevent an average of 280 new asthma diagnoses annually, along with 44 emergency room visits for respiratory issues and over 6,100 lost school days per year.
These figures do not even account for health benefits derived from reduced fine particle emissions.
The Bay Area has already enacted similar rules in 2023, requiring zero-emission water heaters and furnaces, with amendments currently being considered to provide greater compliance flexibility.
Support for the South Coast district’s proposed regulations has surfaced from major urban centers like Los Angeles and Long Beach, although some conservative cities, including Huntington Beach and Fullerton, have expressed their opposition.
image source from：https://lbpost.com/news/climate-change/these-gas-appliances-one-of-the-largest-sources-of-las-smog-could-be-phased-out/
