The recent announcement of a 17% tariff on Mexican tomatoes by the Trump administration has ignited celebrations among Florida-based growers, who have long argued that previous trade agreements allowed an influx of Mexican imports that threatened their market share.
Conversely, greenhouse growers and industry stakeholders from Arizona and Texas are vocally opposing the U.S. Commerce Department’s decision to withdraw from a nearly 30-year-old trade agreement, warning that the move could lead to increased prices and job losses in the American agriculture sector.
“We believe there must be more balanced approaches than imposing tariffs on products that American consumers desire,” said NatureSweet CEO Rodolfo Spielmann, whose company operates tomato greenhouses in both Arizona and Mexico.
Since taking office, President Donald Trump has aggressively pursued a trade war intended to bolster domestic industries while responding to various political pressures. Recently, he even hinted at imposing a 30% tariff on imports from Mexico, citing the nation’s failure to address drug-related issues. However, the tomato tariff is specifically connected to the cessation of the long-standing trade agreement that focused solely on Mexican tomatoes.
NatureSweet’s operations rely heavily on a transborder business model, which complicates any potential reductions in Mexican production. Spielmann noted that shutting down operations in Mexico would negatively impact the company’s domestic facilities.
The vast footprint of NatureSweet’s greenhouse, dwarfed by the size of 30 football fields, was set for an expansion to double its capacity in the United States due to rising consumer demand and potential innovation. However, this plan is now in jeopardy due to the recent shift in trade policy.
Spielmann expressed concerns that the new tariff would disproportionately favor Florida growers, who primarily cultivate tomatoes in open fields, while disadvantaging others, including consumers accustomed to year-round greenhouse-grown tomatoes.
“Our goal should be to protect the entirety of U.S. tomato production,” he stated.
Transitioning more of NatureSweet’s operations to the United States poses numerous challenges, according to Spielmann, who explained that Mexico’s favorable climate for growing tomatoes makes such a shift difficult.
Moreover, the limitations of the H-2A visa program do not reflect the year-round staffing needs of greenhouse operations, further hindering domestic scalability.
As Tom Stenzel, executive director of the Controlled Environment Agriculture Alliance, pointed out, attempting to shift substantial greenhouse resources to the U.S. would require significant time and investment.
Economists have indicated that the new tomato tariff could lead to price increases of up to 10%, ultimately affecting consumers and restaurants that rely on a steady supply of tomatoes.
Industry associations representing companies involved in the distribution of Mexican tomatoes warn that their workforce is now in jeopardy due to this policy change.
“There is a diverse range of tomato varieties, and various factors influence how these products reach grocery store shelves,” emphasized Dante Galeazzi, CEO and president of the Texas International Produce Association, which represents warehouse operators managing imported produce.
The White House has yet to issue a response to inquiries on this matter, instead referring to statements made by Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick upon the announcement of the trade agreement’s termination. He remarked that while Mexico remains a key U.S. ally, American farmers have suffered from unfair trade practices for too long.
Critics of the former agreement assert that its protections did not adequately prevent Mexican tomatoes from being sold at artificial prices in the U.S. market, despite several renegotiations that aimed to create a more equitable trading environment.
Tony DiMare, president of DiMare Fresh, confirmed that protectionism is necessary, stating, “We need boundaries, guidelines, and trade laws to keep these countries in check.”
The decline in the number of family farms over recent years underscores the urgency of the situation, according to Robert Guenther, executive vice president of the Florida Tomato Exchange, which spearheaded the original trade case against Mexican tomato imports.
With Mexican tomatoes now constituting about 70% of the U.S. tomato market, Guenther emphasized the importance of preserving over a century of domestic tomato supply.
Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs, a Democrat, along with political leaders from both parties in Texas and Arizona, have voiced concerns over the potential negative impact of the tomato tariff on local economies.
Hobbs cited a Texas A&M study estimating that nearly 50,000 jobs in her state and Texas are linked to the importation of tomatoes, highlighting significant job vulnerabilities created by this new tariff policy.
image source from：nbcnews
