A new study from Yale University has overturned a long-standing belief in the field of psychiatry regarding the development of psychotic symptoms, revealing that delusions typically emerge before hallucinations in individuals at high risk for psychosis. This finding challenges previous assumptions that hallucinations were the primary drivers of delusional thinking.
Researchers conducted a thorough analysis of symptom progression across three large cohorts, consistently observing that delusions were the earliest symptom to appear, often re-emerging even before hallucinations during relapses. The results of the study imply that disruptions in the brain’s ability to process prediction errors may underlie the formation of delusions, with hallucinations emerging as a secondary consequence.
These critical insights could lead to earlier intervention strategies and improved prevention methods for full-blown psychotic disorders, heralding a new approach to treating conditions such as schizophrenia. In the context of understanding psychotic symptoms, it’s essential to clarify the distinction between delusions and hallucinations. Though both symptoms disrupt a person’s perception of reality, they are not the same.
Delusions are defined as fixed and often bizarre beliefs that persist despite clear evidence to the contrary, such as a person who believes they are a historical figure like the devil and cannot be convinced otherwise. Hallucinations, on the other hand, involve perceiving things that do not exist in reality, such as vividly hearing a voice or seeing an object that is not present.
Historically, much research focused on delusions and hallucinations only after they became fully formed, neglecting the gradual unfolding of these symptoms that can occur over an average duration of 22 months. Initially, delusions may manifest subtly, characterized by an increasing sense of suspicion or unease, while hallucinations can begin with heightened sensory episodes or vague sounds, evolving into more distinct auditory experiences.
Yet, statistics suggest that around 20% of individuals experiencing these early symptoms will progress to developing full-blown psychosis. Dr. Albert Powers, MD, PhD, associate professor of psychiatry and the senior author of the study, expressed the intent of the research: to understand how delusions and hallucinations originate and develop over time, as that understanding can shed light on the underlying causes of these symptoms.
Existing literature has typically treated delusions and hallucinations as a single category due to their similar response to medical treatments. However, focusing on them separately may yield more accurate insights into their relationships. Dr. Powers notes that the prevalent hypothesis assumed that delusions developed as a response to hallucinations, which might create a need for individuals to explain their experiences.
For instance, if someone frequently hears indistinct sounds or footsteps, they might develop a delusion believing that they are being pursued by governmental agents. This theory, while intuitively understandable, is challenged by the findings of the present study.
Through analysis, researchers found that delusions often appeared before hallucinations, upending previous assumptions. The study’s researchers utilized data from three sizable cohorts, primarily focusing on adolescents and young adults in the initial stages of psychosis, as well as including individuals experiencing their first episode of psychosis for comprehensiveness.
Data from the North American Prodrome Longitudinal Study, comprising individuals identified as being at high risk for developing psychosis, and the Montreal-based Prevention Program for Psychosis, was crucial in uncovering the pattern whereby delusions typically appeared before hallucinations. Participants were assessed for their symptoms, including severity, onset, and frequency.
The analysis revealed that among individuals experiencing both symptoms, most reported that delusions appeared prior to hallucinations. Notably, this trend was consistent across all three datasets analyzed. Furthermore, participants disclosed an interesting reversal during remission periods; hallucinations frequently resolved before delusions.
When symptoms re-emerged, however, delusions were reported as having returned before hallucinations yet again. This pattern indicates that delusions may play a prominent role in the early stages of psychosis, potentially driving the subsequent emergence of hallucinations as the brain attempts to interpret its distorted reality.
Emerging theories in psychiatry, grounded in computational neuroscience, offer an explanation for these phenomena. These theories suggest that delusions might arise from disruptions in how individuals learn and interpret information about the world, particularly through the process of ‘predictive processing.’
The framework of predictive processing posits that when individuals have experiences that deviate significantly from their expectations, their brains are prompted to revise those expectations. For example, if a person’s trusty computer suddenly fails to turn on, this creates a prediction error that the brain interprets, leading to the development of new beliefs regarding its functionality.
In individuals suffering from psychosis, dysfunction in neurotransmitter systems may cause hyperexcitability in the cerebral cortex, introducing noise to the processing system. This noise distorts learning about the environment and leads to inaccurate conclusions, ultimately resulting in the formation of false beliefs, or delusions.
For instance, a person may come to misinterpret an innocuous event—like overhearing two people conversing—as something significant related to themselves, believing they are being discussed. As the noise increases, individuals may begin to distrust incoming sensory data, leading them to experience hallucinations based on faulty expectations rather than accurate perceptions.
This disconnect fosters a scenario where hallucinations arise from an overreliance on expectations rather than empirical sensory information. Thus, while the ‘noise’ may lead to delusion formation, it can also compromise how individuals process new information, resulting in hallucinations.
Dr. Powers and his team are hopeful that insights gained from their observations about the development of psychotic symptoms will help transition the field towards preventative measures, allowing medical professionals to intervene before the symptoms manifest fully. Current treatment strategies predominantly address already surfaced symptoms, primarily focusing on managing rather than preventing them.
He draws a comparison to cardiology, wherein professionals not only treat instances of heart attacks but also work to mitigate the risk factors leading to such events, like high cholesterol or blood pressure.
Current psychiatric approaches lack similar proactive strategies, but there is a vision for that to change, particularly if it can be established that the hyperexcitability of certain brain regions underpins the development of delusions and hallucinations.
If this connection is solidified, it may be feasible to intervene earlier in the psychological process before psychosis takes root. Experimental drugs are currently being tested that appear to effectively diminish the hyperexcitability of the cortex, potentially leading to applications for treating early signs of psychosis.
Beyond psychosis treatment, Dr. Powers believes that gaining a deeper comprehension of how the brain misinterprets sensory data could have far-reaching implications across various psychiatric disorders, including depression, anxiety, PTSD, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.
All of these conditions influence the individual’s learning mechanisms about the world and their behavior upon encountering it. Moving forward, the research team aims to conduct a more in-depth analysis of electroencephalogram and magnetic resonance imaging data to pinpoint biomarkers associated with the emergence of psychosis.
In summary, this illuminating research from Yale underscores the importance of separating delusions and hallucinations in the context of psychosis and provides new avenues for understanding their development. Attention to symptom emergence constitutes a significant step toward effective preventative measures in mental health—this study may pave the way for significant innovations in psychiatric care, ultimately benefiting countless individuals at risk for psychosis.
This groundbreaking work received support from the National Institute of Mental Health, alongside various foundations and institutions partnering to enhance the understanding of psychotic disorders.
image source from：https://neurosciencenews.com/delusions-hallucinations-psychosis-28618/
