Nostalgia floods the stage as the 5th Avenue Theatre presents Charles Strouse and Lee Adams’ classic musical “Bye Bye Birdie”. Inspired by the cultural phenomenon of Elvis Presley’s draft into the Army, the production captures both the essence of the 1950s rock and roll era and the humorous chaos that ensues in a small town.
The narrative centers around rock star Conrad Birdie, played by Alex Walton, who faces the prospects of going off to serve in the military. His hapless manager and songwriter, Albert Peterson, portrayed by Noah Weisberg, grapples with the looming loss of his career, while Albert’s girlfriend and secretary, Rosie Alvarez, played by Ashley Pérez Flanagan, sees this as a chance to guide Albert towards a more secure life as an English teacher.
Rosie devises a plan for one last musical hurrah, wherein Albert writes a farewell song, “One Last Kiss,” for Conrad to perform on the Ed Sullivan Show. The twist? The lucky recipient of a kiss from Conrad is Sweet Apple, Ohio teen Kim MacAfee, played by Susanna Cathryn Ballenski. However, the delightful chaos ensues as Kim navigates the challenges presented by an overprotective father, a jealous boyfriend, and a frenzy of adoring fans.
“Bye Bye Birdie” has undergone numerous adaptations throughout its history. The current production at the 5th Avenue Theatre presents a mostly updated version, eliminating several offensive elements, yet it stays true to the original’s sweet and silly spirit. Although the direction by Paige Price opts for a safer rendition, it also keeps the energy alive in this celebrated musical.
While the production does not exceed the lofty expectations of audiences familiar with iconic past performances, it nonetheless provides a series of enjoyable moments. The chemistry between Weisberg and Flanagan is palpable, with standout performances in songs like Weisberg’s heartfelt “Talk to Me” and Flanagan’s lively “Spanish Rose.” The finale number “Rosie” brings the duo together for a triumphant conclusion that lingers in audiences’ minds long after the curtain falls.
Walton shines in the role of Conrad, bringing an infectious swagger to the stage. Leslie Law captures the audience’s affection as Mae Peterson, delivering comedic relief in a maternal role infused with wit. Ballenski’s portrayal of Kim captures the essence of teenage longing and aspiration, effectively engaging the audience.
The production also features lively contributions from the ensemble cast, particularly the youthful Sweet Apple Teens. A surprise moment after the show had audience members celebrating a makeshift high school graduation for actors who had been unable to attend their own ceremonies, enhancing the overall heartwarming experience of the event.
Highlight performances emerge from relatively lesser-known cast members. Tori Gresham steals the scene as the spirited Gloria Rasputin, adding humor and vitality, although her stage time is regrettably brief. Liam Kuriatnyk, who plays Kim’s younger brother Randolph, brings robust vocal talent and excellent comedic timing, suggesting a promising future for the young performer.
In terms of production quality, the set design by Lee Savage, costumes by Melanie Taylor Burgess, and choreography from Jimmy Shields create an engaging, vibrant atmosphere, though they maintain a standard quality without breaking new ground. The band and musical direction under Beth G. Tankersley deserves particular praise for delivering a rockin’ sound that enhances the overall experience.
Overall, the production of “Bye Bye Birdie” at the 5th Avenue Theatre is solid and enjoyable, despite not being groundbreaking. While the show might not floor everyone with its innovation, it still promises a good time filled with laughter and nostalgia. Accordingly, the production earns a rating of YAY- in a three-letter system, signaling a worthwhile but not essential evening at the theatre. For those who have a fondness for classic musicals, this production may still deliver a satisfying experience.
image source from：https://www.broadwayworld.com/seattle/article/Review-BYE-BYE-BIRDIE-at-The-5th-Avenue-Theatre-20250614
