Saturday

04-19-2025 Vol 1935

The Steelers Should Steer Clear of Aaron Rodgers

The Pittsburgh Steelers have a significant decision to make regarding the future of their quarterback position, and former Green Bay Packers star Aaron Rodgers should not be in their plans.

Previously, the stance regarding Rodgers was straightforward: the Minnesota Vikings should decline any potential interest, while the Steelers should consider acquiring him.

However, as time has passed, opinions have shifted. Current assessments suggest that the Steelers should run away from the prospect of signing Rodgers.

Recent comments by Rodgers highlight a decline in his capabilities, making it difficult to justify the burdens of ‘The Aaron Rodgers Experience.’

In an appearance on the Pat McAfee Show, Rodgers did not hold back in criticizing the New York Jets, the team he joined last season, by claiming they brought him across the country “on my own dime” to inform him that they were moving on without him.

He argued that a simple phone call would have sufficed, and subsequently labeled the Jets organization a “debacle,” citing a lack of respect shown to him.

This is particularly relevant for the Steelers since any future issues with Rodgers could lead him to criticize Pittsburgh much like he did the Jets.

When a team undergoes challenges, a player like Rodgers may look for someone else to blame, possibly even targeting the Steelers themselves after his departure.

Moreover, his weekly spot on the Pat McAfee Show allows him a platform to express thoughts and opinions freely, shedding light on his mindset.

Rodgers has earned a reputation for holding grudges and complaining about perceived slights, like his longstanding grievance regarding COVID-19 protocols.

Given this reputation, the question remains: why would the Steelers want to bring on a player who may create more distractions than contributions?

They’ve had enough experience with a quarterback like Ben Roethlisberger, who at one point had his own radio segment until it was clear the public airing of opinions was leading to more issues than it was worth.

It comes down to a crucial question for any organization: do the pros outweigh the cons?

In the current scenario, the cons of having Rodgers on the team seem overwhelming, while the pros remain uncertain, particularly considering his age of 41 and the inevitable decline that comes with it.

While it’s evident that he might be a more competent option than other available players on their roster, the Steelers must explore alternative avenues.

Whether through the draft, trades, or free agency, there are various paths forward that the organization should consider.

Ultimately, the conclusion drawn is that Aaron Rodgers may bring more trouble than he’s worth, with any potential positives failing to outweigh the negatives.

Rodgers’ recent public remarks regarding personal commitments raise further questions about his readiness to commit fully to any team, especially the Steelers.

If he wasn’t prepared to engage extensively, a visit to the Steelers seems unnecessary and raises further doubts about his intentions.

Thus, the Steelers are urged to take the initiative for themselves; they can undoubtedly find better options moving forward.

This sentiment focuses not just on throwing skills but significantly on leadership, emotional intelligence, and self-awareness within the quarterback position, essential traits for any successful team.

image source from:https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/steelers-should-move-on-from-aaron-rodgers

Benjamin Clarke