In New York City, crime remains a central concern for voters, with rising migrant-related offenses drawing significant attention and criticism.
The city’s current progressive city council and deep-rooted bureaucratic resistance have continued to obstruct cooperation with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), deepening frustrations among citizens.
The forthcoming mayor has the opportunity to break this deadlock by facilitating the deportation of unlawful immigrants who have committed crimes.
Under the legacy of former Mayor Bill de Blasio, a series of laws were enacted that have effectively established the city’s sanctuary status.
Local Law 58, for instance, prohibits federal immigration authorities from establishing an office on Rikers Island, the city’s jail, while Local Law 228 restricts city agencies from honoring federal immigration detainers without a judicial warrant for specified serious crimes.
Additionally, Intro 486 and Intro 487 impose strict limits on cooperation between the Department of Correction and the New York Police Department and federal detainer requests, allowing such requests only for certain serious or violent crimes when validated by a judicial warrant.
These policies, while politically advantageous for de Blasio, seem ill-suited to confront the realities of the city’s ongoing migrant crisis.
Recent incidents, such as a tragic subway fire involving a migrant, have intensified calls for policy revision.
In another alarming case, two convicted gang members from Venezuela found themselves released without bail, despite facing serious felony charges; such occurrences have escalated public anxiety over safety.
Rather than pursue an indiscriminate approach to immigration enforcement, the next mayor should advocate for policies that clearly separate lawful residents from those accused of crimes.
By notifying ICE when a migrant is charged with a criminal offense, federal authorities can prioritize the removal of individuals posing a threat to public safety, while still portraying New York City as a haven for peaceable individuals.
A Siena poll indicates that a significant number of New Yorkers—79 percent—support the deportation of illegal immigrants convicted of crimes, with 48 percent favoring state backing for federal immigration enforcement efforts.
In addition to legislative changes, the next mayor can leverage executive orders to restore an ICE office at Rikers Island, following the initiative launched by First Deputy Mayor Randy Mastro.
Although a recent city council lawsuit has temporarily halted this order, the push to reopen the ICE office is a critical step in the right direction, highlighting the importance of collaboration with federal agencies in enforcing the law.
Beyond the city borders, collaboration with neighboring Nassau County presents a strategic opportunity.
Nassau County has actively engaged in immigration enforcement through participation in the Immigration and Naturalization Act’s 287(g) program, allowing ICE to work with local law enforcement in identifying illegal immigrants in custody.
Under County Executive Bruce Blakeman, Nassau has implemented this program effectively, addressing shared immigration issues such as human trafficking and theft, which also impact New York City.
For example, an illegal immigrant has recently been charged with operating a prostitution ring that spanned both Queens and Nassau, underscoring the interconnectedness of crime across these jurisdictions.
In light of the potential political unpalatability of a direct partnership with the Trump administration’s ICE, New York City’s next mayor should consider collaborating with Nassau County officials more closely.
This partnership could include forming a joint task force between the NYPD and Nassau County police, facilitating the transfer of criminal aliens to Nassau for expedited removal proceedings.
The next mayor must embrace and utilize the various tools available to ensure the safety of New Yorkers, especially as crime, particularly those related to immigration, continues to rise.
New Yorkers are seeking leadership that prioritizes their safety while balancing the complexities of immigration and public security.
Addressing these issues head-on is essential for restoring confidence and security in the city.
image source from：https://www.city-journal.org/article/new-york-city-mayor-crime-immigration-deport-sanctuary
